Search results
The Brenner debate was a major debate amongst Marxist historians during the late 1970s and early 1980s, regarding the origins of capitalism. The debate began with Robert Brenner 's 1976 journal article "Agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe", published in the influential historical journal Past & Present.
Oct 27, 2009 · The Brenner Debate - October 1985. Robert Brenner's challenging article, “Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe”, published in issue no. 70 of Past and Present (February 1976), initiated a debate of intense interest, not only to historians, but to all concerned with the causes behind transitions between successive social formations.
Jan 2, 2010 · Key to Brenner’s argument is the fact that agricultural change was substantially different in England and France; so he insists that an adequate causal explanation must identify a factor that varies similarly. From the distance of several decades, the dividing lines of the Brenner debate are pretty clear.
The essentials of Robert Brenner's argument have been put forward many times before by a long and distinguished line of proponents. The counter-argument is also securely placed in historiography. Consequently, there is much to be said for simply referring readers to previous publications.
Oct 23, 2018 · To me, Brenner’s argument has a lot in common with the “new institutional economics.” T hat is the economic approach that starts (as most economics does) with individual self-interest, but sees in an era’s institutions—its customs, laws, and traditions—forces that shape and change individuals’ behavior.
The Brenner Debate, which reprints from Past and Present various article in 1976, is a scholarly presentation of a variety of points of view, covering a very wide range in time, place and type of approach. Weighty theoretical responses to Brenner's first formulation followed from the late Sir Michael Postan, John Hatcher, Emmanuel Le Roy ...
People also ask
What was the Brenner Debate?
What is Brenner's argument?
Why did Robert Brenner write the article 'Agrarian class structure & economic development'?
Is the transition debate a 'Brenner Debate'?
What is Brenner's approach to class struggle?
Why does Bois criticize Brenner?
PII: S0486-6134(00)00081-4. 1. Introduction. Robert Brenner’s extended essay, “Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe” (1976), including the whole debate it generated in the same pages of Past and Present, subsequently republished in book form as The Brenner Debate (Aston & Philpin, 1987), may no longer ...
