Search results
Mar 12, 2022 · Andrea was offered $10,000 to help kill Peggy. To back up her alibi, Diana left her phone with Tanisha Joyner in Washington DC and drove down to Valley Cottage. Later, Andrea told the police that as she and Diana walked down the stairs with Peggy, she used a pocketbook strap to choke Peggy.
Apr 22, 2020 · Once inside the home, Diana stabbed Peggy before the pair fled the scene. Diana eventually plead guilty to first-degree murder, and admitted that money was her motive.
Mar 6, 2015 · Upon arriving at 644 Andover Road after 1 a.m. on January 25, Diana Nadell and Andrea Benson murdered Peggy Nadell. Peggy Nadell suffered strangulation, multiple blunt force trauma wounds...
- Lanning Taliaferro
Aug 21, 2014 · According to an indictment filed in June, Nadell went to Washington, D.C., the night before the murder where she met Andrea Benson, a 25-year-old D.C. resident. She offered Benson $10,000 to help...
- Gail Sullivan
Aug 20, 2014 · Police said Diana Nadell and an accomplice lured Peggy Nadell to the door of her Valley Cottage, N.Y., home with a late-night phone call Jan. 25, then killed her. The suspect allegedly wanted...
Dec 14, 2023 · Now, in December 1988, the new suspects in the eyes of the investigators were the Carr family’s neighbors — Diana and George James Trepal. During their subsequent interrogation, the latter actually unpromptedly commented on how the poisoner likely wanted the Carrs to move out, which was eerily similar to the anonymous note.
Sep 16, 2019 · Then in October, only two days before Peggy had fallen sick, Diana went to the Carrs’ home in a rage. The family recalls that Diana was “screaming and cussing and yelling,” “ranting and...
