Search results
Abstract. This chapter turns to the second and (I argue) the more important criterion for free will, namely, ultimate responsibility (UR). A series of theses are defended that explain what this criterion entails and why it is incompatible with determinism. In the process, the chapter critically examines new compatibilist accounts of free will ...
that to be more free is to be able to satisfy more of our desires. In a free so-ciety, we can buy what we want and travel where we please. We can choose what movies to see, what books to read, whom to vote for. But these freedoms are what you might call surface freedoms. What we mean by free willruns deeper than these ordinary freedoms. To see how,
- 199KB
- 33
Nov 13, 2015 · Near the end of his essay, Robert Kane says that “agents who exercise free will are both authors of and characters in their own stories all at once. By virtue of ‘self-forming’ judgments of the will ( arbitria voluntatis) (SFA’s), they are ‘arbiters’ of their own lives, ‘making themselves’ out of a past that, if they are truly ...
Kane shows a comprehensive mastery of the historical and contemporary literature on free will. He is careful, fairminded, and even generous to his adversaries (a trait lamentably rare in debates about free will). Having said the above, I now proceed to spend most of this piece focusing on places of disagreement.
Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Libertarians still argue against compatibilism... What is the "origination argument" (Kane) 1. Originator 2. Determinism. 3.Freedom, So, is it true you are responsible if and only if you could have done otherwise? An evil scientist gives you an implant ruling out 1/2 of all choices, would a semi-compatibilist say you are ...
For Kane, ultimate responsibility is the core idea in the traditional definition of free will. He says: Free will, in the traditional sense I want to retrieve (and the sense in which the term will be used throughout this book), is the power of agents to be the ultimate creators (or originators) and sustainers of their own ends or purposes.
People also ask
What does Kane mean by ultimate responsibility?
What is Kane's model of moral responsibility?
Who is Robert Kane?
Is Kane right about quantum uncertainty?
Kane's classical compatibilism. classical compatibilism is the belief determinism is compatible with free will. 1. We have the choice / ability to do what we want and 2. we are not constrained (physically, coercion, compulsion) What is freedom of will according to compatibilists. Unconstrained freedom of choice/decision.
