Search results
Quick answer: In "If—," Kipling means that one should treat triumph and disaster "just the same" by viewing both success and failure as impostors. This perspective advises handling both with...
Apr 21, 2024 · The poem advises treating both success and failure with equanimity, recognizing that they are both fleeting and deceptive. Kipling is advocating for a Stoic approach to life, where one is not overly attached to external outcomes.
George Orwell called it “a good bad poem.” The apparent simplicity is ultimately complex. Kipling proposes that these superhuman feats — impossible courage and stoicism — make one a ‘man’.
Dec 5, 2015 · He says that Success and Failure are a part and parcel of life and there is nothing permanent about them. The poet calls them impostors since both success and failure are powerful and have a disguise of permanence which makes a person feel either too optimistic or broken down.
Nov 27, 2023 · A good winner or loser is someone who, upon facing failure or success, does not appear happy or sad at the win or loss, then that person is one who is far more stoic in nature.
Nov 7, 2020 · Kipling extends the concepts of success and failure, saying that we should be able to lose everything we’ve earned and still have the motivation to build it back up, as well as never complaining to others about the loss.
People also ask
What is a lesson from the poem Success & Failure?
What does Kipling say about success and failure?
Is if by Rudyard Kipling a stoicism poem?
Is 'if' a good bad poem?
What is the Poet's Word of advice for a misfortune?
How does the poem reinforce capitalist ideologies?
Nov 24, 2023 · Here, Kipling presents the idea that both success (Triumph) and failure (Disaster) are temporary and often misleading. The lines urge the reader to maintain a level-headed perspective, neither being overly elated by triumph nor devastated by disaster.
